Emergency Tooth Extraction in Brooklyn, NY

Urgent removal of a tooth that cannot be saved and is causing pain or infection.

What Is an Emergency Tooth Extraction?

An emergency extraction is the removal of a tooth that cannot be saved and is causing acute pain, infection, or risk of further complications. While saving a natural tooth is always the preferred outcome, there are situations where extraction is the most responsible course of action. Teeth that are severely fractured, extensively decayed, abscessed beyond treatment, or causing dangerous swelling may need to be removed immediately to protect the patient’s health and eliminate the source of the problem.

Emergency Tooth Extraction: Quick Facts

Quick factTypical answer
Number of visits1
Time needed20 to 60 minutes
AnesthesiaLocal anesthesia
Recovery timeA few days to a week
Next stepReplacement planning once healed

These are typical ranges. Your own plan is confirmed after an examination.

When an Emergency Extraction Is Needed

Extraction is the right choice when a tooth cannot be restored and leaving it would allow pain or infection to continue. Whenever a tooth can be saved, that option is explained first.

  • A tooth fractured below the gum or split through the root
  • Severe decay with too little tooth left to restore
  • An infection that root canal treatment cannot resolve
  • A tooth severely loosened by gum disease or injury
  • An impacted wisdom tooth with acute infection

Emergency Tooth Extraction at Bensonhurst Dental Care

At Bensonhurst Dental Care, emergency extractions are performed with the same level of care and planning as scheduled procedures, adapted for the urgency of the situation. The dental team evaluates the tooth, surrounding bone, and soft tissue using clinical examination and digital imaging to determine the safest approach. Local anesthesia ensures the patient is comfortable throughout. Whether the case requires a simple or surgical extraction approach, the goal is to remove the tooth efficiently, manage infection if present, and set the patient up for a smooth recovery.

What to Expect, Step by Step

  1. Assessment. Examination and X-ray confirm the tooth cannot be saved.
  2. Options. Alternatives and replacement options are discussed.
  3. Numbing. Local anesthesia is given.
  4. Extraction. The tooth is removed, simply or surgically.
  5. Socket care. The socket is cleaned and grafted if planned.
  6. Aftercare. Instructions and medications are provided.

Save the tooth or extract it?

SituationUsually possible to save?Typical treatment
Deep decay with sound rootsYesRoot canal and crown
Cracked cuspYesCrown
Vertical root fractureNoExtraction
Advanced bone loss with severe mobilityOften notExtraction
Abscess with a restorable toothYesDrainage and root canal

An extraction ends the emergency. Deciding how to replace the tooth is what protects the rest of the mouth.

What to Do Now and After Treatment

Looking after yourself

Before you reach us

  • Take pain relief and avoid chewing on the tooth
  • Do not apply heat to your face
  • Come in as soon as possible

After your emergency visit

  • Protect the blood clot: no rinsing, spitting, straws or smoking for 24 hours
  • Begin warm salt-water rinses on day two and eat soft foods
  • Return to discuss replacement

When to Call Us

Call the office on (718) 234-3434 if you notice any of the following:

  • Bleeding that does not stop
  • Severe pain two to four days later, which may be a dry socket
  • Swelling or fever

What Happens Next

After an emergency extraction, the dental team discusses the next steps, including healing expectations and tooth replacement options. Socket preservation may be performed at the time of extraction to maintain the bone for a future dental implant. Planning for replacement early, even in an emergency context, ensures the patient avoids the long-term consequences of a missing tooth, including shifting, bone loss, and bite changes.

Cost and Insurance

An emergency visit has two parts: the visit that stops the pain or infection, and the treatment that fixes the cause. You are told the fee for each before it is carried out.

What affects the cost

  • The examination and X-rays needed to find the cause
  • The treatment given at the emergency visit
  • The definitive treatment that follows, such as a root canal, crown or extraction
  • Medication, if prescribed

Most dental plans contribute to emergency examinations and to the treatment that follows. Our team can check your benefits and explain your options before treatment begins.

Meet the doctor

Dr. Alex Rubinshtein

Dentist with more than 22 years of experience and a DDS from NYU, where he was an honor society member. Uses the latest advances in dentistry to provide personalized patient care.

Learn more about doctor
Dr. Alex Rubinshtein, laser dentist at Bensonhurst Dental in Brooklyn

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I need an emergency extraction?

An emergency extraction may be needed when a tooth is causing severe uncontrollable pain, when an infection is spreading and cannot be managed with antibiotics alone, when a fracture has made the tooth unsalvageable, or when a tooth is at risk of causing damage to adjacent teeth or structures. The dental team makes this determination after a thorough evaluation.

Is an emergency extraction painful?

The procedure is performed under local anesthesia, so the extraction itself is not painful. Many patients find that the relief from eliminating the source of infection or pain is immediate and significant. Post-operative discomfort is managed with medication and aftercare instructions.

What happens after an emergency extraction?

Patients receive detailed aftercare instructions to support healing. A follow-up appointment is typically scheduled to check the site and discuss replacement options. If socket preservation was performed, healing progresses over the following months in preparation for an implant or other restoration.

Can an emergency extraction be avoided?

In some cases, early intervention with treatments such as root canal therapy, crowns, or periodontal care can save a tooth that might otherwise need emergency extraction. This is one of the reasons regular dental exams and prompt treatment of emerging problems are so important.

Will I be able to get an implant after an emergency extraction?

In most cases, yes. Implant placement is typically possible after the extraction site has healed, usually three to six months later. Socket preservation at the time of extraction helps ensure the bone is maintained for optimal implant placement.

What Our Patients Say

I had my jaw broken 4 months prior to coming to Bensonhurst Dental and it was fought to find a dentist that would be able to work with me in my situation. When I first came to Bensonhurst Dental, they were able to figure out exactly what was wrong and what needed to be done and I am thankful for that! If it wasn’t for them, I don’t know what I would’ve done.

I absolutely love everything about this place. The staff is friendly and the dental team defines perfectionism. I truly always have a great experience here and leave with a big smile😀 …

After having bad experiences with other dentists, this place was a breathe of fresh air. Everyone is very welcoming, professional and helpful. Perfect smile loading...

It feels like home; excellent services and always there to help in a dental emergency.... Great vibes...Great people....so much love! I have never had a problem with them!!!

This establishment is great. My wife and I really enjoyed the staff that greated us like superstars. Pleasant environment with great Doctors. I will definitely recommend this practice to all my friends and family.

Eric O'Neal (opens in a new tab)

Local Guide · 43 reviews · 73 photos

I have always been not comfortable going to the dentist however going to Bensonhurst dental care I not only feel comfortable also at ease my experience is always excellent I had two teeth extracted yesterday I felt calm and very relaxed returned today for a follow up I am healing very well treated great I will recommend Bensonhurst dental care to anyone five stars always

4.8 stars531 reviews on Google (opens in a new tab)